Truths and Lies of Statistics

A completely true fact can also be very deceptive.
How is it possible? As usual, the problem is not in the data but in the people. For a computer, data is not more than that: it is not good or bad, it is not much or little. But people always value the data: we want to know what they mean, whether they are important or not, or whether we should be happy or worried.
At first reaction, we do not process the information: we perceive it . Perception is a quick way to categorize the avalanche of “inputs” we receive, but it is also the equivalent of a security hole: it opens the door to manipulation.
There are many types of manipulation. These are some of the most common:
▪ It can draw attention to debates that “omit” some points of view that they want to hide (as Noam Chomsky tells )
▪ You can play with the vocabulary to give something positive or negative connotations, or to eliminate positive or negative connotations (ex: “collateral damage”)
▪ You can highlight some figures or others: for example, we can compare the last economic data with the best or the worst in history, with the previous month, with the same month of the previous year; or we can compare the accumulated of the year with the accumulated of the previous year. Depending on our interests, we can choose the comparison that most benefits us
▪ Or you can play with the same pair of data and present it in different ways: the impact on our perception can be impressive (via Tim O’Reilly )
The conclusion: the data itself does not deceive, but we must be critical of the selection (what information is highlighted and which is omitted), the presentation and, consequently, our perception.


No Comments

Write a Reply or Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Me

Over the years, we have worked with Fortune 500s and brand-new startups.These companies may have an international presence or focus strictly on a local clientele, and we can still deliver the results they need.